“Soul Survivors” Podcast: Investigating the Reasons Behind Its Abrupt Cancellation

The abrupt cessation of Premier Christianity’s “Soul Survivors” podcast has left many listeners puzzled and concerned. The series, which delved into the allegations against Soul Survivor founder Mike Pilavachi, was lauded for its investigative depth and empathetic storytelling. Hosted by Megan Cornwell, a journalist with a background at The Guardian and The Tablet, the podcast aimed to shed light on the misuse of power within the Church.

In July 2024, Cornwell announced her resignation from Premier Christian Communications, stating on social media:

“I have resigned from Premier Christian Communications. Please direct all future questions about
series 5 of the Soul Survivors podcast to the Executive Producers.”

This unexpected departure coincided with the podcast’s sudden halt, leading to speculation about internal challenges or external pressures influencing its discontinuation.

The timing of the podcast’s suspension is particularly noteworthy. In April 2024, worship leaders Matt and Beth Redman released a documentary titled “Let There Be Light,” where they candidly discussed their experiences with Pilavachi’s abusive behaviour during their time at Soul Survivor.  Their participation in the podcast provided firsthand accounts that were both compelling and essential for understanding the broader implications of the scandal.

The podcast’s impact was further evidenced by its recognition within the industry. It was nominated for Podcast of the Year at the 2024 Professional Publishers Association (PPA) Awards, highlighting its significance and the quality of its journalism. Additionally, the series attracted a substantial global audience, reflecting the widespread resonance of its content.

The decision to cease the podcast, especially after such significant contributions, raises questions about the factors leading to its termination. While Premier Christianity has not provided a detailed explanation, the overlap between Cornwell’s resignation and the podcast’s abrupt end suggests potential internal conflicts or external pressures that may have influenced these decisions.

This situation highlights a broader concern within Christian media and institutions: the marginalisation of voices, particularly those of women, who challenge established power structures. The Church’s handling of such scandals and the platforms that report on them play a crucial role in fostering transparency and accountability. The discontinuation of “Soul Survivors” underscores the challenges faced by journalists and survivors in bringing these issues to light.

As the Church grapples with the aftermath of the Soul Survivor scandal, it is imperative to support and amplify the voices dedicated to truth and reform. The experiences shared by individuals like the Redmans and the investigative efforts of journalists like Cornwell are vital for the Church’s journey toward healing and integrity.

The decision to axe the “Soul Survivors” podcast - after its ground-breaking revelations and vital contributions - demands scrutiny. Was it silenced to protect the Church from disclosures so damning they could bring Soul Survivor, and perhaps broader institutions, to their knees? The timing of Megan Cornwell’s resignation and the abrupt podcast cancellation reeks of a calculated move to shield powerful figures and preserve a crumbling façade. Was her hand forced? Was she compelled to resign?

What truths were buried by shutting this down? Was the podcast poised to expose systemic failures, unchecked abuse, or complicity at the highest levels? The lack of transparency only fuels suspicion that what lies hidden is far more damaging than anything already revealed.

This silencing is not just a blow to survivors but a chilling message to anyone daring to speak truth to power: your voice will be erased if it threatens the status quo. It underscores a disturbing trend in Christian institutions - the suppression of those who challenge entrenched hierarchies and demand accountability.

The Church’s reputation cannot outweigh the need for justice. The cancellation of the “Soul Survivors” podcast raises the stakes, leaving us to question: what secrets are so catastrophic they must be smothered at all costs? And who benefits from this veil of silence?

If the Church truly seeks healing and redemption, it must embrace transparency, not cower behind closed doors. Anything less is complicity in the very harm it claims to condemn.